7 Comments
User's avatar
Zachary McClanahan's avatar

This breakdown is sharp. These ideological battles aren’t just about politics but about deep pathological forces shaping society. The Left’s cultural dominance isn’t just pervasive; it’s an oppressive force that dictates institutions, social norms, and even individual thought. This goes beyond political disagreements. It is psychological conditioning, leveraging shame and fear to enforce compliance. The existing political framework is too compromised to counterbalance this, making reform within it feel futile. A completely new party or movement is necessary, one that rejects the ideological stranglehold and restores a foundation of sanity.

Expand full comment
Mark Travis's avatar

I agree with this analysis. One relevant point that the “woke center” aka “classical liberals”/alt-center harp upon in their argument ad hitlerum, is that the so-called “woke right” wants to part ways with the us constitution, which essentially constitutes a slippery slope, if not a precipice. I think this is worth discussing, but, unfortunately, the woke center is unable to engage in good faith, as you’ve pointed out.

In terms of ponerology, without such guardrails, what keeps such counter-revolution from pathocracy? If we look at the script from early 20th century Europe, the counter-revolutions were in many cases as bad or worse than the leftists they defeated.

Expand full comment
Mark Travis's avatar

Example here: https://x.com/jessekellydc/status/1913666740447326616?s=46&t=EZlrfU9r0Eb594IDxyXTZA

Assuming Trump continues faithfully following the constitution, allowing bureaucrats and the judiciary to squelch any chance of restoring the republic. When thependulum swings around again, the gloves come off.

Expand full comment
Mark Travis's avatar

Also, let’s call them “woke center” because of their hysterical argument im at hitlerum and refusal to engage in good faith.

Expand full comment
Leo M.J. Aurini's avatar

This was fantastic. If you're looking for essay idea, I, for one, would love to hear you expound upon the Oedipal condition - I'm only slightly familiar with Freud, and I'll bet a lot of others are only familiar with the dumb version of Freud. I'd love to hear it in your own words.

Expand full comment
J.D. Haltigan's avatar

It could be a part IV perhaps. Were you able to trace back to parts 1 & 2 for coherency? That may provide some insights for you.

Expand full comment
Leo M.J. Aurini's avatar

Read through all of them, although it my reading was bookending 12 hour work days. I may give them a second read through, now that I'm on days off.

Expand full comment