8 Comments
User's avatar
aliza c's avatar

Im feeling this tension in my first year of my msw program. Ive always been liberal, im a Californian who's spent a lot of time in activism circles - so I intentionally chose a private Christian university to be more balanced.

Ive been SHOCKED to find that all the same DEI education in @ this university as it was in California undergrad!

While the DEI itself isn't what bugs me, its the extreme "resocializing" you mentioned directed at conservative students. Its the biasness I find uncomfortable.

Thanks for helping me, probably a "hardcore liberal" 🥲😂 learn how harmful political bias are!

Stuart Rose's avatar

Best of luck getting along (not going along) in that environment. I hope that doesn’t sound snarky or cynical. Maybe connecting with some social work students/teachers outside of the college would be a valuable thing to do— I mean, find people who you can both vent to and get counsel on how to navigate things.

Erin Pyper, MSW's avatar

“We also question whether the workforce is “ready” to meet students who pursue a “prochange mandate” at all costs—and are unprofessionally trained in the techniques of permanent political struggle—instead of abiding by relevant laws and policies.” You both rightfully express a concern in the social work field, and I value professional competence. Well done!

Erin Pyper, MSW's avatar

Of course! I do not like when ideology gets into social work practice. Keep speaking the truth.

Paving the Way's avatar

There never should have been clinical social work. Social work is social work. I believe it happened because the females in hospitals threatened their male doctor bosses for more money and status. So, they threw them a bone.

Arnold Cantú's avatar

I think Specht and Courtney make a similar argument critical of clinical social work in their classic 1994 book "Unfaithful Angels: How Social Work Has Abandoned its Mission." See: https://scholarworks.wmich.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2245&context=jssw

Paving the Way's avatar

What is we had a real psychotherapy profession that helped people?